Democratize the Budget

RE should seek student input on major purchases

Vladimir Ponomarenko, Antonia Pinnar '25, Matthew Pollak '25, Kayra Serpenguzel '25, Mia Bouyoucef '25, Matias Blanco '25, Beatriz Lindemann '25, Abby Pollak '26, Kenzie Kaplan '25, and Luiza Bell '25 • November 1, 2024

A brand-new, massive, cutting-edge LED scoreboard now towers over the Robert E. Walker Field, equipped with the ability to not only keep score, but also display videos and photos of players and probably predict the weather if you ask it nicely. RE’s acquisition of the smart scorekeeper was certainly not cheap, costing upwards of $40,000. This behemoth has prompted new discussions and questions around how the school decides how funding between sports is divided—which teams receive state-of-the-art luxuries, and which are left to fend for themselves.

While field sports such as RE Football stand to benefit from the new scoreboard, other teams have faced tightening budgets this year. Several teams at RE are required to travel for matches and meets. In the past, the costs for hotels were covered by the school. However, RE has begun to require students to pay for their own hotels out of their RE Bookstore accounts. The school only covers one hotel per season.

In addition, this year, the girls’ cross-country team no longer received bottoms for their uniforms, placing them at risk of disqualification unless they purchased their own shorts individually.

Our issue is not with the so-called ‘jumbotron’ itself, which is inarguably a beautiful addition to Robert E. Walker Field. The problem is that few, if any, RE students even knew it was being installed until they saw it on the field after returning to campus.

Students and parents deserve transparency regarding where funding is going. Making sure RE families at the very least know about these big purchases would help foster the sense of community and accountability the RE Way strives for.

The same funds used to purchase the ‘jumbotron’ could have been allocated in a way that worked to meet the immediate needs of a wider variety of students. Those needs will remain invisible, and will not be met, unless students are asked for their opinions.

RE needs more student involvement in financial decisions.

RE could start by creating more opportunities for discussion between students and the administration. We propose the establishment of a Student Budget Commitee. Essentially, students would form a committee that would work closely with administrators to review budget proposals and offer their ideas on how to distribute resources more equitably. This would improve the relationship between students and the administration, ensuring future purchases are made with a clearer understanding of student priorities.

RE should also hold open budget forums throughout the year. These forums would invite students to participate in discussions about the school’s spending decisions, ensuring their voices are heard before any major purchases are made. Administrators could use these opportunities to explain the rationale behind expensive purchases, such as the ‘jumbotron,’ helping students understand the decision-making process and the factors involved. At the same time, these forums would give students the chance to express their concerns, ask questions, or propose alternative ways the money could be spent to better meet the needs of the student body.

RE could also explore a more innovative approach: participatory budgeting. This system would involve setting aside a portion of the student budget specifically for students to decide how it’s spent. This system would allow students to propose projects that they feel would benefit the school most. After the submission of proposals, the entire student body would vote on which projects receive funding, ensuring that the budget reflects the needs and interests of the majority.

Ultimately, increasing student involvement in budget decisions would create a more equitable distribution of resources, while creating a stronger connection between the student body and the administration. By giving student a seat at the table in these discussions, RE can make financial decisions that reflect the diverse needs of the student body and generate a positive impact for the greatest number of individuals. This embrace of financial transparency and dialogue is critical to the creation of a more inclusive environment in which all students feel heard.

About the Contributors

Antonia Pinnar '25, Managing Editor

Antonia Pinnar ‘25, a senior at Ransom Everglades School, is the managing editor for The Catalyst. She’s the Vice President of the Volunteer Service Council and is involved in Students Against Gun Violence. Antonia plans on pursing her passions for journalism, law, and politics in the future.

Matthew Pollak '25, Media Editor

Matthew is the current Media Editor and previously a sports editor for the Catalyst. He loves watching sports, producing music, and playing golf.

Kayra Serpenguzel '25, Hard News Editor

Kayra Serpenguzel ‘25, a senior at Ransom Everglades School, is the hard news editor for The Catalyst. She’s the President of the RE Speech and Debate Team, and is involved in the Sailing Team, Poetry Club, Environmental and Sustainability Council, and Rock 4 Relief (Rock Band) at her school. Kayra hopes to pursue her passions for journalism, law and politics in the future.

Mia Bouyoucef '25, Opinion Editor

Mia Bouyoucef is a senior at Ransom Everglades and opinion editor. She has a strong interest in media studies, global geopolitics, and sustainability. Outside of the Catalyst, Mia is the president of the Miami Youth Climate Summit and the Politics and Current Events Club, editor-in-chief of ConScience (an RE sustainability magazine), an Extemper and World Schools Debater, a Student Government representative, and a sailor.

Matias Blanco '25, Feature Editor

Matias Blanco ‘25, a senior at Ransom Everglades, is the Feature Editor for The Catalyst. In this role, he edits unbiased interview-based stories. Outside of the newspaper, Matias is a HIP PHE, a Production Manager for TEDxRE, and a Senior Delegate in Model United Nations.

Beatriz Lindemann '25, Arts Editor

Beatriz Lindemann ‘25, a senior at Ransom Everglades School, is the Arts Editor for The Catalyst. She is the president of the Gender and Sexuality Association and Captain of the Girl’s Crew Team. She is also involved with Student’s Against Gun Violence. Beatriz’s writing has been published in several publications including Women’s Media Center and Blue Marble Review. She hopes to study journalism, law, and politics in college and beyond.

Abby Pollak '26, Sports Editor

Abby Pollak, a junior at Ransom Everglades School and the sports editor for the Catalyst, leads with her passion for sports and journalism. As captain of the RE girls golf team and a player for the National Women’s Lacrosse Team of Peru, Abby brings dedication and insight to both the field and her writing. She hopes to pursue her love of journalism further in the future.

Kenzie Kaplan '25, Web Editor

Kenzie Kaplan '25, a senior at Ransom Everglades School, is one of the Web Editors for The Catalyst. She serves as President of Students Against Gun Violence, Vice President of Symphonettes Miami, a HIP PHE, Captain of the Cross Country Team, and a member of the Track and Field Team. Kenzie was also awarded a Bowden Fellowship in the Humanities, through which she conducted research in Argentina. She aspires to pursue a career in law and journalism in the future.

Luiza Bell '25, Web Editor

Luiza Bell ‘25 is a senior at Ransom Everglades and a Web Editor for the Catalyst. She is the Director or PR and Marketing for TedX and a member of Model UN and Brazilian Culture Club at school. Outside of school, Luiza is the Director of Communications for Enough for Everyone, a nonprofit, student-run women's health organization. Luiza has been contributing to the Catalyst for the past 4 years, and hopes to pursue her passion for journalism and marketing in the future.